 Assets (13).png)
Table of Contents
- Introduction: Why Unicorn Gifts Matter at Age Five
- Self-Care & Wellness: Building Healthy Routines Early
- Pretend Play & Imagination: Spark Creativity the Safe Way
- Beyond Self-Care & Pretend Play
- Early Learning & STEM: Building Skills Through Play
- Arts & Creativity: Encouraging Expression and Fine Motor Growth
- Comfort & Emotional Security: Unicorn Gifts for 5-Year-Olds that Soothe and Support
- Conclusion: Choosing Unicorn Gifts for 5-Year-Olds With Confidence
- Popsicle Beauty Club Unicorn Recommendations
- Other Unicorn Gift Ideas to Consider
- FAQs
Introduction: Why Unicorn Gifts Matter at Age Five
By age five, children are moving through a critical stage of development: their imagination is in full bloom, their fine motor skills are strengthening, and they’re beginning to stretch their attention spans beyond quick bursts of play. Unicorn gifts for 5 year olds play an important role at this stage—they can either encourage healthy growth and safe exploration, or they can introduce unnecessary risks.
Unicorn-themed presents are especially powerful because they meet children where they are: full of wonder, drawn to bright colors, and eager to play pretend. But as moms, we know the sparkle isn’t enough. We need to make sure the unicorn gifts we bring into our homes are non-toxic, skin-safe, and developmentally supportive. That means looking past flashy packaging and asking: Does this product nurture my child’s imagination, protect her health, and give her confidence in daily routines?
In this guide, you’ll find recommendations that balance magic with mom-approved standards—gifts that feel enchanting to your five-year-old while giving you peace of mind that they’re safe, purposeful, and age-appropriate.
Self-Care & Wellness: Building Healthy Routines Early
At age five, children are just beginning to form daily habits around hygiene, grooming, and self-care. Research shows that when routines like brushing teeth, washing up, or moisturizing are made fun and engaging, kids are far more likely to build positive lifelong habits. Unicorn gifts for 5 year olds that fall into the self-care category—like bath products, balms, and accessories—turn everyday routines into moments of joy instead of battles.
Why It Matters
Children’s skin at this age is thinner and more permeable than adults’, which means it absorbs ingredients more easily. That makes it critical to choose products that are plant-based, non-toxic, and free from hormone-disrupting chemicals. The goal is to let her enjoy the sparkle and ritual while you rest assured that every ingredient is safe for her growing body.
A Magical Example
One standout option is a unicorn-inspired balm that combines safety with a sense of wonder.
Unicorn Balm: This organic, plant-based balm delivers multi-purpose shimmer with safe, skin-loving ingredients, all packaged in sustainable materials. Infused with coconut oil, locally sourced lilac blossoms, roses, and pure mineral-based mica glitter, it gives a sheer, glossy finish while nourishing and moisturizing—whether it’s on lips, cheekbones, or even cuticles. She’ll feel extra special with a jar made just for her—each one handcrafted in small batches—and you’ll appreciate knowing it keeps her skin soft, nourished, and protected.
Unicorn Balm
$14.99
This organic, plant-based balm delivers multi-purpose shimmer with safe, skin-loving ingredients, all packaged in sustainable materials. Infused with coconut oil, locally sourced lilac blossoms, roses, and pure mineral-based mica glitter, it gives a sheer, glossy finish while nourishing and moisturizing—whether… read more
Pretend Play & Imagination: Spark Creativity the Safe Way
Five-year-olds live in a world where imagination drives learning. Pretend play isn’t just dress-up—it’s how children experiment with identity, practice problem-solving, and learn to empathize. According to child development research, role-playing strengthens social-emotional skills and encourages flexible thinking, making it one of the most valuable types of play at this age. Unicorn gifts for 5 year olds that involve safe, non-toxic makeup or dress-up sets give kids a magical way to play while protecting their health.
Why It Matters
Because pretend play often involves applying makeup, costumes, or accessories directly to skin, it’s important that every product is designed with children’s safety in mind. Many mass-market “kids’ makeup” sets are treated as toys, not cosmetics, which means they can legally bypass ingredient safety regulations. That loophole is why choosing non-toxic, EWG-verified, and heavy-metal-tested products is essential for peace of mind. If you’ve ever wondered how unsafe ingredients slip into kids’ products, read more about why talc-free makeup matters and the scandals tied to it here.
Unicorn Makeup That Moms Can Trust
For moms who want to encourage imaginative beauty play without sacrificing safety, these unicorn-inspired picks make the experience both magical and worry-free:
5-Piece Unicorn Makeup for Kids
Encourage creativity with this natural pressed powder and lip gloss makeup set, formulated with vibrant mineral pigments and a non-toxic, skin-friendly base parents have trusted since 2016. As the longest-standing clean beauty brand for kids, they’ve led the way in making safe play makeup that’s gentle on delicate skin and easy to wash off. Each product is carefully formulated for sensitive skin: powders are nut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, and dairy-free (coconut-derived oil, no almond oil), while the lip gloss is nut-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, and free of wheat derivatives. Free from parabens, talc, synthetic dyes, artificial fragrances, phthalates, and other hidden toxins, this set delivers peace of mind for moms and pure fun for kids.
What’s Included:
2 Natural Pressed Eyeshadows – Mix and match for playful, colorful looks
1 Lip Gloss Wand (Birthday Cake) – A sweet, transparent glossy finish made with plant-based ingredients
2 Nail Sticker Sheets (Unicorn Magic) – Playful designs to decorate nails or add fun face art
1 Eco-Friendly Bamboo Makeup Brush – Lightweight & perfectly sized for little hands
5-Piece Strawberry Cupcake, Mermaid or Unicorn Makeup for Kids
$29.99
Encourage creativity with this natural pressed powder & lip gloss makeup set, formulated with vibrant mineral pigments and a non-toxic, skin-friendly base parents have trusted since 2016. As the longest-standing clean beauty brand for kids, they've led the way in… read more
Blue Unicorn Cat Makeup Sponge
Make makeup play safer and more realistic with this soft, latex-free sponge, thoughtfully designed for little hands and sensitive skin. Its unique multi-use shape features flat sides for sculpting, a thin top for tiny creases, and a wide base for blending all over. Perfect for play makeup, face paint, or “just-like-Mommy” routines, it encourages realistic application while staying gentle on skin. Moms can feel confident knowing it’s free from allergens commonly found in adult sponges, keeping pretend play safe and irritation-free.
Non-Toxic Makeup Sponge
$4.99
Make makeup play safer and more realistic with our soft, latex-free makeup sponges, thoughtfully designed for little hands and sensitive skin. Perfect for blending play makeup, face paint, or pretending to do a “just-like-Mommy” routine, these playful sponges turn makeup… read more
9-Piece Unicorn Makeup Set for Kids
Let her imagination sparkle—safely—with this natural pressed powder makeup set, made with vibrant mineral pigments and a trusted, skin-friendly formula. This is our most allergy-conscious kit yet: powders are nut-free, gluten-free, soy-free, and dairy-free (coconut-derived oil, no almond oil), while the lip gloss is nut-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, and free of wheat derivatives. Each piece is designed to be safe for children and kind to the planet, completely free of parabens, talc, synthetic dyes, artificial fragrances, phthalates, and other hidden toxins. From first experiments to daily creative play, this unicorn kit makes beauty fun while keeping safety first.
What’s Included:
3 Natural Pressed Eyeshadows – Mix and match for playful, colorful looks
1 Natural Pressed Blush – A soft pastel peach for a natural flush
1 Lip Gloss Wand (Strawberry Cupcake) – A sweet, transparent glossy finish made with plant-based ingredients
2 Nail Sticker Sheets (Unicorn Magic & Ice Cream) – Fun designs to decorate nails or add face art
1 Eco-Friendly Bamboo Makeup Brush – Lightweight & perfectly sized for little hands
1 Latex-Free Sponge Applicator – Mess-free powder application, neatly stored away
9-Piece Mermaid or Unicorn Makeup Set for Kids
$49.99
Let her imagination sparkle—safely. This Natural Pressed Powder Makeup Set is made with vibrant mineral pigments and a non-toxic, skin-friendly formula trusted by parents since 2016. As the longest-standing clean beauty brand for kids, they've led the way in creating… read more
10-Piece Rose Gold Unicorn Makeup Brushes with Rainbow Diamond Case
We’re absolutely enchanted by these rose gold unicorn brushes—and here’s why you will be too. Whether she’s brushing shimmer on a doll’s cheeks or practicing first “real” techniques, these brushes make beauty play safe and imaginative. The whimsical handles pair with an iridescent rainbow case shaped like a diamond, keeping everything organized between uses. With a full range of tools from eyeshadow to contour, this brush set builds skills while inspiring hours of creative play.
What’s Included:
10 Rose Gold Unicorn Makeup Brushes – Full range of sizes for eyes, face, and detail work
1 Rainbow Diamond-Shaped Case – Iridescent storage case to protect and organize brushes
10-Piece Rose Gold Unicorn Makeup Brushes with Rainbow Diamond Case
$29.99
We’re absolutely enchanted by these rose gold unicorn makeup brushes — and here’s why you will be too. Whether it’s your tween experimenting with beauty for the first time or your toddler brushing a favorite doll’s cheeks, these unicorn eyeshadow… read more
Beyond Self-Care & Pretend Play
Unicorns don’t just show up in beauty play—they’ve become a favorite across almost every corner of childhood. Once you’ve stocked her vanity with safe, non-toxic products, you may want to explore other unicorn gifts for 5 year olds that nurture different parts of her growth and development. From puzzles that build focus and problem-solving skills, to art kits that strengthen fine motor coordination, to plush companions that ease nighttime fears, unicorns can spark joy while supporting the skills she needs most at age five. Here’s what to look for in these categories to make sure the magic stays fun, purposeful, and safe.
Early Learning & STEM: Building Skills Through Play
At age five, children are rapidly developing cognitive abilities—they’re learning to recognize patterns, solve problems, and focus for longer stretches of time. Play that challenges these skills in a fun, accessible way helps prepare them for school success and builds confidence in their ability to try, fail, and try again. Unicorn gifts for 5 year olds that include puzzles, building sets, or books turn essential brain-building into exciting, colorful fun.
Why It Matters
Research shows that puzzles, building sets, and early reader books all strengthen neural pathways related to problem-solving and persistence. Introducing unicorn themes into these activities makes them instantly more engaging, capturing a child’s natural sense of wonder while reinforcing key learning skills.
What Moms Should Look For
Eco-Friendly Materials: Wooden puzzles finished with non-toxic, water-based paints are safer and more durable than plastic sets.
Safe Printing: Books printed with soy-based inks or FSC-certified paper reduce exposure to harmful chemicals.
Age-Appropriate Challenge: Look for puzzles with 24–48 pieces, or simple building kits, which provide just the right level of difficulty for five-year-olds without causing frustration.
By pairing safe, eco-conscious materials with a magical unicorn theme, moms can give their kids gifts that don’t just entertain—they actively support brain development and confidence.
Arts & Creativity: Encouraging Expression and Fine Motor Growth
At five years old, children are developing the fine motor control that lays the foundation for handwriting and other school skills. Arts and crafts not only provide a creative outlet but also give kids the opportunity to practice gripping, cutting, coloring, and sequencing—all of which strengthen coordination and hand muscles. Unicorn gifts for 5 year olds that include coloring books, stickers, or craft kits help children practice these skills while keeping them excited and engaged.
Why It Matters
Studies show that creative activities like drawing and crafting build both fine motor precision and self-expression. When paired with imaginative themes like unicorns, children are more motivated to stay engaged, which means longer practice times and greater skill-building.
What Moms Should Look For
Non-Toxic, Washable Supplies: Crayons, markers, and paints should be free from VOCs, parabens, and synthetic dyes to protect sensitive skin and respiratory systems.
Plant-Based or Low-VOC Options: Safer formulas reduce exposure to allergens and toxins, while still providing vibrant color.
Engaging Unicorn Themes: Sticker books, coloring sets, or DIY craft kits that feature unicorns keep kids inspired while reinforcing patience and focus.
With the right materials, unicorn-themed arts and crafts do more than entertain—they help children develop the fine motor skills, creativity, and confidence they’ll carry into school and beyond.
Comfort & Emotional Security: Unicorn Gifts for 5-Year-Olds that Soothe and Support
Five-year-olds are still learning how to manage big feelings—whether it’s separation anxiety at bedtime or the need for reassurance during transitions. Unicorn-themed comfort items can provide a sense of stability, helping children feel safe and cared for in moments of stress.
Why It Matters
Psychologists note that transitional objects, like plush toys or blankets, support emotional regulation and self-soothing. Pairing these essentials with the magic of unicorns makes them even more appealing, giving kids both comfort and joy in a single gift.
What Moms Should Look For
Hypoallergenic Materials: Choose plush toys or bedding made from organic cotton or hypoallergenic polyester filling to reduce the risk of skin irritation.
Safe Lighting: LED unicorn night lights should stay cool to the touch and be free of BPA and PVC plastics.
Breathable Fabrics: When it comes to bedding, prioritize materials that allow airflow to support safe, comfortable sleep.
These unicorn gifts for 5 year olds don’t just look adorable—they also create a foundation of emotional security, easing nighttime fears and giving moms peace of mind that comfort and safety go hand in hand.
Conclusion: Choosing Unicorn Gifts for 5-Year-Olds With Confidence
Moms know that the best gifts aren’t just fun in the moment—they also protect health, nurture creativity, and build confidence. Unicorn gifts for 5 year olds check all those boxes when chosen thoughtfully, blending magic with meaningful developmental benefits. The challenge is separating flashy packaging from products that are truly safe, purposeful, and made for growing bodies.
By leaning on clean, non-toxic self-care items, imaginative play kits, and thoughtfully chosen books, crafts, or comfort items, you can give her the sparkle she loves without compromise. Whether it’s a shimmer balm that doubles as skin nourishment, a puzzle that challenges her focus, or a plush that helps her feel secure at night, unicorn-themed treasures deliver both wonder and wellness.
Popsicle Beauty Club Unicorn Recommendations
These are unicorn-themed products you’ll find at Popsicle Beauty Club—each one science-backed, parent-approved, and designed with non-toxic safety in mind:
Unicorn Balm – Organic, plant-based balm with coconut oil, lilac, rose, and mica shimmer; perfect for lips, cheeks, or cuticles.
5-Piece Unicorn Makeup for Kids – Natural pressed eyeshadows, lip gloss, nail stickers, and bamboo brush.
Blue Unicorn Cat Makeup Sponge – Latex-free, multi-use sponge sized for little hands.
9-Piece Unicorn Makeup Set for Kids – Expanded pressed powder palette, blush, gloss, stickers, bamboo brush, and sponge applicator.
10-Piece Rose Gold Unicorn Makeup Brushes with Rainbow Diamond Case – Full brush range with whimsical handles and diamond-shaped storage case.
Other Unicorn Gift Ideas to Consider
Even beyond self-care and pretend play, unicorns can make learning and comfort magical. Here are other unicorn gifts for 5 year olds worth exploring:
Early Learning & STEM:
Wooden unicorn puzzles with non-toxic, water-based paints
Unicorn-themed early reader books printed with soy-based inks
Eco-friendly building sets that strengthen problem-solving skills
Arts & Creativity:
Unicorn coloring books with washable, non-toxic markers
Sticker activity sets that support sequencing and fine motor skills
DIY unicorn craft kits with safe, plant-based glues and dyes
Comfort & Emotional Security:
Organic cotton unicorn plush toy with hypoallergenic stuffing
Unicorn LED night light made from BPA-free materials
Unicorn bedding sets made with breathable, Oeko-Tex certified fabrics
With so many options out there, choosing unicorn gifts for 5 year olds doesn’t have to feel overwhelming. By focusing on non-toxic, developmentally supportive, and joy-filled picks, you’ll give her gifts that are magical today and meaningful for years to come. For safe, science-backed beauty play, Popsicle Beauty Club is here to help moms shop with confidence.
Encourage creative, toxin-free play with our guide: The Ultimate Guide to Non-Toxic Play for Kids, where you'll find eco-friendly dress-up ideas, DIY play makeup, and safe role-playing alternatives.
About the Author: Rebecca is a Penn State–educated entrepreneur and mom of six, with a career spanning renewable energy, hydrogen fuel innovation, and plant-based wellness. She’s the founder of Popsicle Beauty Club, a clean, non-toxic self-care brand for kids rooted in ingredient safety and environmental responsibility. To learn more or connect, you can find Rebecca on LinkedIn.
FAQs
Are unicorn makeup kits safe for 5-year-olds?
Most mass-market “kids’ makeup” kits are treated as toys, which means they don’t go through the same safety testing as cosmetics. That can leave room for hidden risks like parabens, phthalates, synthetic dyes, or even trace heavy metals. The safest unicorn makeup kits for 5-year-olds are made with natural, plant-based ingredients, tested for skin safety, and completely free of hormone-disrupting chemicals. Always check the ingredient list and buy from brands that are transparent about what goes inside.
What makes a good unicorn gift for a 5-year-old?
The best unicorn gifts balance fun with developmental benefits. For this age, look for gifts that support creativity (like art kits), problem-solving (like puzzles), or independence (like self-care items). Always choose products made from non-toxic, eco-friendly materials so they’re gentle on both your child and the planet.
Should I avoid glitter in unicorn gifts?
Not all glitter is created equal. Conventional plastic glitter can shed microplastics that irritate skin and harm the environment. For unicorn gifts for 5 year olds, choose products with biodegradable or mineral-based glitter (like mica), which provides the same sparkle without the hidden toxins.
How do I know if a unicorn gift is developmentally appropriate?
At five, kids thrive with activities that build fine motor skills, problem-solving, and imaginative role play. Unicorn-themed puzzles, craft kits, books, and pretend play sets are excellent choices. Avoid products with tiny, detachable parts that could pose a choking hazard, and aim for toys labeled 3+ or 4+ with clear safety standards.
What are some non-toy unicorn gift ideas?
Unicorns don’t have to stop at toys or makeup. Look for practical gifts like unicorn-themed bedding, pajamas, or LED night lights that bring comfort and routine. These types of gifts support emotional security and can make daily transitions—like bedtime—feel magical.
